✦

13–20 minutes

read

·

3,110 words

✦

24. Silence for Silence

, ,

Ominis Gaunt is paying attention, and Evelyn has to find out what his silence will cost.

⚠️ Content warnings: blackmail

Home / Fan Works / First, Do No Harm

<-PreviousFirstNext->

Evelyn

I found Sebastian on Friday morning in the passage below the Great Hall, where the Slytherins came up from the dungeons to breakfast. He was not alone. Ominis walked a pace behind him with his wand held out in front of him, its tip glowing a faint red.

I had meant to catch Sebastian alone. I had not slept enough to be clever about it.

“Evie.” Sebastian stopped. His eyes went to my face and then, quickly, to my hands. “You look terrible.”

“Thank you.” I had the flask in my pocket, wrapped in its cloth with the folded sheet of instructions round it and a twist of string to hold them. I took it out and held it towards him, low, between us. “For Feldcroft. It isn’t what I promised. Read the paper before you send it.”

He did not take it at once. He looked at it. For a moment his face was a boy’s face, younger than I had seen it since fifth year.

“What is it?”

“Something for the pain. And her hands.” I kept my voice down. “It won’t touch the curse. I don’t know how well it will do what it does. That’s why I need you to write everything down. Every dose. What she says. What you see. I need to know.”

He took it then. He turned it over once in his fingers, feeling the warmth of the glass through the cloth, and put it inside his robes.

Behind him Ominis had stopped walking.

He did not come closer. He stood where he was in the middle of the passage with his head a little on one side, the red light at the end of his wand gone still, as though he were listening to a noise too high for anybody else to hear. His face was turned towards us. Not to Sebastian. To the place where the flask had been.

“What is that?” he said.

“Post,” said Sebastian. “For Anne.”

“Post.”

“Some of us write to her, Ominis.”

It was cruelly done. I saw it land. Ominis’s mouth went thin. He said nothing else. After a moment he turned and went on up the stairs to the Hall alone, the red light going ahead of him. Sebastian let out a breath.

“You shouldn’t have said that,” I said.

“I know.” He did not look sorry. He looked tired, and older again. “I’ll send it today. I’ll write.” He hesitated. “Evie. Thank you.”

“Don’t thank me yet,” I said. “It may do nothing at all.”

It was a long week after that. I wrote out my account of the silver Wiggenweld three times in my best hand, for Blainey and for Penhallow and for myself. Every copy took an evening. I went to the Room every night after and worked on Rookwood’s knot until the old magic began to pull at my fingers and I had to stop. Leander walked me to lessons and to meals and to the foot of the Ravenclaw stair. He did not ask where I went afterwards. I noticed him not asking. I did not tell him.

On the Tuesday Garreth caught us both after supper and marched us into the library, to the table at the back under the window where nobody could see us from the desk. He laid out a sheet of paper with 4th December written across the top and underlined twice.

“Sunday,” he said. “The moon’s up before four. I’ve looked in three almanacs and they all say the same, so it’s true.” He tapped the paper. “Which means you’re gone from lunch. Sunday lunch, you’re feeling poorly. I take you up. Everybody sees me take you. Then I come back down and eat your pudding, because that’s what I’d do, and everybody knows it.”

“You’d eat it anyway,” said Leander.

“I would. That’s why it works.” He made a note. “Supper, I say you’re asleep. Nobody will want to wake you. That’s fine. It’s Monday that’s the trouble.” He looked at me. “He’ll look like death on Monday.”

“He’ll look like a fever,” I said. “We’ve used fever.”

“Twice. Third time, somebody’s going to send for a Healer, and I don’t mean you.”

Leander was quiet a moment. “Quidditch,” he said.

“You’re not on the team.”

“I could fall off a broom on Sunday morning. Practice. I’m very good at falling off things.” He did not smile. “Ask anyone. I fall out of bed.”

Garreth snorted. Then he looked at the paper, and then at Leander, and then he wrote broom in the margin and drew a box round it.

I sat with them for an hour while they argued it out, and helped where I could, and watched the two of them bent over the one sheet of paper with their heads nearly touching. A fortnight ago I had been carrying all of it alone. Now there were three of us at a table under a window, and Garreth was drawing boxes round lies so that I would not have to tell them. I had not known how heavy it was until somebody else put a hand under it.

And all the while the knot was waiting in its drawer on the seventh floor, and I said nothing about it to either of them.

Ominis did not speak to me all week. In Defence he sat where he always sat, two places along from Sebastian. When Hecat set us to pairs he paired with Amit and not with either of us. Once, on the Wednesday, I came into the library and found him at a table near the door with a book open in front of him and his wand held low over the page, the red light moving slowly along the lines. He lifted his head as I passed. He did not say anything. I went on to my own table and sat with my back to him and felt him there, the whole afternoon, as you feel a draught.

On Friday Sebastian came and found me.

He did it in the open, in the corridor outside Charms, with half the seventh year going past. He fell into step beside me as if we had walked together every day since fifth year. He held a letter low against his side so that only I could see it.

“She slept,” he said.

I stopped walking. Somebody behind me said something rude and went round.

“All night,” said Sebastian. “Tuesday and Wednesday both. First time since the summer.” He turned the letter so I could see the hand. It was Anne’s, and it went from margin to margin, line after line, the whole page. “She wrote that herself. All of it. Look at it, Evie. It doesn’t shake.”

I looked at it. I could not read it for a moment. Then I could. Tell Evie, the last line said, I don’t know what she’s done, but tell her I slept.

“Anything else?” I said. My voice did not sound like mine. “Pain? Sickness? I need all of it, Sebastian.”

“A headache, in the mornings. A taste of metal. She says it’s nothing.” His mouth twisted. “She says everything’s nothing.”

“Silver,” I said, half to myself. “There’s silver in it. Too much, if she tastes it. Halve the dose for a week and tell me if the headaches go.” I took a breath. “And tell me if anything gets worse. Anything at all.”

“I will.” He folded the letter away. “You actually did it, Evie.”

“No,” I said. “Not yet. Don’t tell her I did.”

“I won’t.” He looked at me a moment longer, as if he were trying to work out what I was. Then he looked away. Still not looking at me, he said, “She wrote to Ominis too. Told him she was better. He came and asked me why.”

“What did you tell him?”

“Nothing.” Sebastian looked at me then. There was something in his eyes I did not like. “He doesn’t believe in nothing, Evie. He never has.”

Ominis found me on Monday.

He did not find me so much as wait for me. I came out of Defence behind the others, and he was standing by the door with his wand held still, and as I passed him he said, without turning his head, “The Undercroft. After supper. Come alone.” Then he went away down the corridor before I could answer.

I had been to the Undercroft once this year, on the night of the forest, to buy Nan’s memory from Sebastian. I went down after supper by the old way, through the door that was not a door. The room was as it had been that night: the cold brazier, the scorched flagstones, the chalk targets on the far wall where Sebastian had taught me things I had not yet understood I should never have learnt. Ominis had not lit the brazier. He did not need it. He was sitting on the bench beside it in the dark, very straight, with his hands folded in his lap.

I lit the brazier with a flick of my wand. It did not make the room any warmer.

“You came,” he said.

“You asked me to.”

“I didn’t ask.” He turned his face towards me. In the torchlight his eyes were pale and fixed a little to the left of me. “Sit down, Evelyn.”

I sat on the bench across from him. The brazier was between us, and all of fifth year with it.

“I have always been able to feel magic,” Ominis said. “Not see it. Feel it. As other people feel weather coming. Most of it is nothing. Charms are nothing. Potions are mostly nothing.” He paused. “Ten days ago you handed Sebastian something in a cloth, and it was not nothing. It was old. It had the feel of the things in this room that we should never have opened.” His folded hands tightened. “And it had the feel of you.”

I said nothing.

“It is on you now,” he said quietly. “Not strongly. Like smoke on a coat. You have been working with something old, every night, for weeks.”

“Yes,” I said.

That surprised him. I saw it go across his face.

“Rookwood,” he said.

“Rookwood’s notes. Not his methods. His notes on how Anne’s curse was made.” I kept my hands flat on my knees. “I am trying to find the end of it, Ominis. It was tied to her from outside. If it was tied it can be untied. I haven’t found how yet. The thing I gave Sebastian on Friday week isn’t a cure. It eases her. That’s all.”

“She slept,” he said.

“Yes.”

“She wrote to me.” His voice did not change, but his hands did. They came apart in his lap and lay open. “She wrote a whole page. I had it read to me twice. She said she didn’t know what had happened, only that she slept, and that her hands had stopped. She said she was going to try to walk to the end of the lane next Sunday.”

I had not known that. Sebastian had not told me that.

“Then it’s working,” I said.

“That is what frightens me.” He leaned forward a little. “I have watched what this kind of magic does to people who mean well with it. I watched it in this room. I watched what it did to Sebastian. I am not going to watch it again and say nothing.”

“I’m not asking you to say nothing about that.” My heart was going hard. “If it turns, if anything I do for her turns dark, you go to Weasley. You go to Black. You can go to anyone you like. I won’t stop you, and I won’t blame you.”

He was silent a long moment.

“And Sebastian,” he said. “What does he owe you, Evelyn?”

I did not answer.

“He owes you something. I know him. He would not take a thing like that from you, or from anybody, unless he had already paid for it, or was going to.” His blind eyes did not move from the place beside my head. “What did you buy with a cure for Anne?”

I thought of Nan in the hospital wing, screaming at dawn about a clearing she could not remember. I thought of Sebastian’s wand at her temple in the dark, and his face afterwards. It was not mine to tell. It was mine, every bit of it. It was the worst thing I had ever asked of anyone.

“I’d rather not say,” I said.

Ominis sat back. Something that was nearly a smile went over his face and was gone.

“That is not a lie,” he said.

“No.”

“Sebastian would have lied.”

“I know.”

He was quiet again. Somewhere in the walls water was running, as it always had down here. I remembered the sound of it from fifth year, under Sebastian’s voice and the crack of spells against the far wall.

“What do you want from me?” he said at last.

“Stay out of my way. Keep quiet about what you felt on Friday week, and what you feel on me now. That’s all.” I made myself go on. “And when it works, if it works, you’ll know first. Before Sebastian, if you like. You can take it to her yourself. You can be the one who sees it.”

His hands closed.

“You think that’s a fair price,” he said.

“I think it’s the only thing I have that you want.”

For a moment I thought he would get up and go. Then he let out a breath, long and slow. When he spoke again his voice had changed.

“Then I’ll want something else as well,” he said. “You won’t tell Anne I asked. And you won’t tell Sebastian I came here.”

I looked at him. At the straight back and the folded hands and the pale eyes turned a little to the left of me.

“Silence for silence,” I said.

“If you like.” He stood up and came round the brazier towards the door. He stopped beside me. “If it turns, Evelyn, I will go to Weasley myself. I want you to know that. I won’t care what it costs Sebastian, or what it costs you.”

“I know.”

“Good.” He lifted his wand. The red light came up at its tip again. “Put the fire out when you go. I’d rather nobody knew we’d been here.”

He went out. I sat on in the cold with the brazier hissing in front of me and the chalk targets pale on the far wall.

I had liked him. In fifth year, before Solomon and before any of this, Ominis had been the one person in the castle who could keep pace with me in an argument and enjoy it. He would take a thing I said, turn it over and hand it back sharper. I had missed that since fifth year without once letting myself name it. Tonight he had sat across a brazier from me and bargained as coolly as a goblin at Gringotts, and I had matched him, and neither of us had smiled once. I would have given a good deal to hear him laugh at me again.

Then I put the fire out, as he had asked, and went up through the dark the old way.

On the stairs I counted it up, as I would have counted the ward stores against the ledger. I had promised Anne’s cure to Sebastian, and bought Nan’s memory with it. Now I had promised the first sight of it to Ominis, and bought his silence. Anne herself I had promised nothing at all, and she had been paying all along, with every night she had not slept since the summer. I did not have the cure. I had a flask of something that let her sleep, and a knot I could not find the end of, and two debts already written against it. If it never came I would owe three people a thing I could not give. And one of them was a girl who meant to walk to the end of a lane next Sunday because of a flask I had made.

It was late when I came out into the corridor below Ravenclaw Tower. Leander was sitting on the bottom step of our stair in his shirtsleeves and waistcoat, with a book open on his knee that he was not reading. He shut it when he saw me and stood up.

“There you are,” he said.

“It’s not your night for rounds.”

“No.” He looked at me. He had a way of looking that took in everything at once: the dust on the hem of my skirt, the cold in my hands, the smell of brazier smoke in my hair. I watched him take it all in. “You’ve been somewhere cold.”

“Yes.”

“Every night this week you’ve been somewhere.” He said it gently. He was not accusing me. I would have known what to do with that. “I don’t mind, Evie. I don’t need to know where you go. Only you look worse every morning, and I’d like to know if there’s anything I can carry.”

I wanted to tell him. I wanted it so badly that I could feel the words in my mouth: Anne, and Rookwood, and the knot, and what the knot had cost and who had paid for it. Nan’s face in the hospital wing. Sebastian’s wand. It would have been the easiest thing in the world, and it would have been the end of something, and I did not know what.

“It’s Sebastian’s business,” I said. “I’d rather not say.”

He went still. He knew those words. He had heard me say them to Penhallow last week, and he had sat beside me on a step afterwards and been glad of them.

“All right,” he said, after a moment.

He did not argue. He did not ask again. He kissed my forehead, lightly, said goodnight and went away down the corridor with his book under his arm. I stood at the foot of the stair and watched him go.

It was the truth. I had not lied to him. I had only kept something, and he had let me keep it. I went up to bed and lay awake a long time with that.

<-PreviousFirstNext->

✦

Thank you for reading

Did this chapter make you gasp, grin or throw your phone across the room? Tell me in the comments below. I read every single one.

Every chapter here is free. If you’d like to say thank you, you can buy me a coffee.

Want new chapters the moment they’re posted? Pop your email in below. You can choose which stories you follow.

Leave a Reply